Current:Home > FinanceDelaware Supreme Court reverses ruling invalidating early voting and permanent absentee status laws -Infinite Edge Learning
Delaware Supreme Court reverses ruling invalidating early voting and permanent absentee status laws
View
Date:2025-04-21 06:10:21
DOVER, Del. (AP) — Delaware’s Supreme Court on Friday reversed a judge’s ruling that state laws allowing early voting and permanent absentee status are unconstitutional.
The Supreme Court did not address the merits of the case, but it instead found only that the plaintiffs, a state elections inspector and a Republican lawmaker, did not have legal standing to challenge the laws.
Justice Gary Traynor said elections inspector Michael Mennella and Senate Minority Leader Gerald Hocker had not met their burden of establishing “imminent or particularized harm.” To achieve standing, he said, a plaintiff must demonstrate an injury that is “more than a generalized grievance” shared by the population at large.
“Because we have concluded that the plaintiffs do not have standing, we do not reach the merits of their state constitutional claims,” Traynor wrote in an opinion for the court.
The justices said Hocker did not establish standing as a purported candidate because he will not stand for reelection until 2026. “That election, in our view, is not imminent,” Traynor wrote.
The court also rejected Mennella’s argument that he has standing as an inspector of elections and would have the authority to turn away voters based on his belief that the laws are unconstitutional.
The justices also said Hocker and Mennella did not have standing to assert their constitutional claims by virtue of their status as registered voters whose votes would be diluted by illegally cast votes.
In a concurring opinion, Justice Karen Valihura agreed that Hocker did not establish standing as a candidate, and Mennella’s status as an election inspector also was not sufficient. But she said her colleagues went too far in focusing on lawsuits over the 2020 presidential election while addressing the thorny issue of registered voter standing.
“I believe that the highly expedited nature of this proceeding counsels for a narrower holding that identifies and reserves for another day a more careful delineation of the boundaries of registered voter standing,” Valihura wrote.
The court issued its ruling just three weeks after hearing oral arguments, and less than three months before the Sept. 10 primary elections.
The ruling comes after Superior Court Judge Mark Conner declared in February that Mennella and Hocker had shown by “clear and convincing evidence” that the laws were “inconsistent with our constitution.”
Conner’s ruling came after the Supreme Court declared in 2022 that laws allowing universal voting by mail and Election Day registration in general elections were unconstitutional. The justices said the vote-by-mail statute impermissibly expanded absentee voting eligibility, while same-day registration conflicted with registration periods spelled out in the constitution.
In his ruling, Conner said a 2019 law allowing in-person voting for at least 10 days before an election violated a constitutional provision stating that general elections must be held on the Tuesday following the first Monday in November. “Our constitution provides only one such day, not any day or series of days the General Assembly sees fit,” he wrote.
Conner also found that, under Delaware’s constitution, voters can request absentee status only for specific elections at which they cannot appear at the polls. Under a law dating to 2010, however, a person who voted absentee one year because of the flu could continue to vote absentee in all future general elections, Conner noted.
veryGood! (26)
Related
- John Galliano out at Maison Margiela, capping year of fashion designer musical chairs
- Thanksgiving is a key day for NHL standings: Who will make the playoffs?
- Search resumes for the missing after landslide leaves 3 dead in Alaska fishing community
- Judge says evidence shows Tesla and Elon Musk knew about flawed autopilot system
- Juan Soto to be introduced by Mets at Citi Field after striking record $765 million, 15
- South Louisiana pipe fabricator’s planned expansion is expected to create 32 new jobs
- Jason Kelce’s Wife Kylie Sets the Record Straight on Taylor Swift Comment
- Walmart shooter who injured 4 in Ohio may have been motivated by racial extremism, FBI says
- See you latte: Starbucks plans to cut 30% of its menu
- Gov. Kathy Hochul outlines steps New York will take to combat threats of violence and radicalization
Ranking
- Google unveils a quantum chip. Could it help unlock the universe's deepest secrets?
- FBI ends investigation of car wreck at Niagara Falls bridge, no indication of terrorism
- Dolly Parton is Cowboys' halftime star for Thanksgiving: How to watch, livestream
- Georgia Supreme Court ruling prevents GOP-backed commission from beginning to discipline prosecutors
- Man can't find second winning lottery ticket, sues over $394 million jackpot, lawsuit says
- Georgia Supreme Court ruling prevents GOP-backed commission from beginning to discipline prosecutors
- Geno Smith injury updates: Seahawks optimistic on QB's chances to play vs. 49ers
- 28 Black Friday 2023 Home Deals That Are Too Good to Pass Up, From Dyson to Pottery Barn
Recommendation
The Louvre will be renovated and the 'Mona Lisa' will have her own room
Turkey’s central bank hikes interest rates again as it tries to tame eye-watering inflation
Drew Brees reveals lingering impacts of NFL injury: 'My right arm does not work'
FBI ends investigation of car wreck at Niagara Falls bridge, no indication of terrorism
Pregnant Kylie Kelce Shares Hilarious Question Her Daughter Asked Jason Kelce Amid Rising Fame
Nicaragua’s Miss Universe title win exposes deep political divide in the Central American country
Sea turtle nests break records on US beaches, but global warming threatens their survival
Apple announces iPhones will support RCS, easing messaging with Android